User:Testingthisthing/ArbCom2019: Difference between revisions
Content added Content deleted
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
#Kudpung |
#Kudpung |
||
#*Acts irrationally frequently, is short-tempered and a knee-jerker. |
#*Acts irrationally frequently, is short-tempered and a knee-jerker. |
||
#Maxim |
#Maxim {{tick}} |
||
#*Has made some good closes as a bureaucrat. |
#*Has made some good closes as a bureaucrat. |
||
#Richwales |
#Richwales |
||
#*Not familiar with. |
#*Not familiar with. |
||
#Bradv |
#Bradv {{tick}} |
||
#*Does good job although sometimes unable to look at POV from both sides. Part of a clique that regularly gangs up on good faith editors. But I feel he would still be a good arbitrator. |
#*Does good job although sometimes unable to look at POV from both sides. Part of a clique that regularly gangs up on good faith editors. But I feel he would still be a good arbitrator. |
||
#Casliber |
#Casliber {{tick}} |
||
#*Not familiar with. Seen them around and has had positive interactions so I have good impression. |
#*Not familiar with. Seen them around and has had positive interactions so I have good impression. |
||
#Calidum |
#Calidum |
||
Line 19: | Line 19: | ||
#Thryduulf |
#Thryduulf |
||
#*Has demonstrated incompetence in several areas. |
#*Has demonstrated incompetence in several areas. |
||
#Enterprisey |
#Enterprisey {{tick}} |
||
#*Rarely gets involved in the administrative side but does good technical work. Not sure if he would be a good arb but typically the quiet ones make the best decisions. |
#*Rarely gets involved in the administrative side but does good technical work. Not sure if he would be a good arb but typically the quiet ones make the best decisions. |
||
#KrakatoaKatie |
#KrakatoaKatie {{tick}} |
||
#*Outgoing arb who has done a good job thus far. |
#*Outgoing arb who has done a good job thus far. |
||
#Llywrch |
#Llywrch |
||
#*Not familiar with. |
#*Not familiar with. |
||
#Newyorkbrad |
#Newyorkbrad {{tick}} |
||
#*Former arb who's arguably the greatest English Wikipedia arbitrator of all time. |
#*Former arb who's arguably the greatest English Wikipedia arbitrator of all time. |
||
#Xeno |
#Xeno |
||
Line 31: | Line 31: | ||
#David Fuchs |
#David Fuchs |
||
#*Not familiar with. |
#*Not familiar with. |
||
#Beeblebrox |
#Beeblebrox {{tick}} |
||
#*Has made good reasonable closes. |
#*Has made good reasonable closes. |
||
#SoWhy |
#SoWhy {{tick}} |
||
#*A bit rigid and tight on policy but might be a good thing for some balance in the committee. |
#*A bit rigid and tight on policy but might be a good thing for some balance in the committee. |
||
#Worm That Turned |
#Worm That Turned {{tick}} |
||
#*Outgoing arb, has been great. |
#*Outgoing arb, has been great. |
||
#Isarra |
#Isarra |
||
#*Not familiar with. |
#*Not familiar with. |
||
#Barkeep49 |
#Barkeep49 {{tick}} |
||
#*Follower of the letter of law rather than the spirit. Other than that, they've been excellent. |
#*Follower of the letter of law rather than the spirit. Other than that, they've been excellent. |
||
#DGG |
#DGG {{tick}} |
||
#*Former arb if I'm not mistaken, has shown good judgement. |
#*Former arb if I'm not mistaken, has shown good judgement. |
||
#The Rambling Man |
#The Rambling Man |